4 February 2021
For the first time, researchers have proved human-caused global warming is directly responsible for creating a ‘critical threat’ of a devastating outburst flood - putting a city of some 120,000 people in the path of potential floodwaters, according to new research from the University of Oxford and the University of Washington, published in Nature Geoscience.
As the planet warms, retreating glaciers contribute to the formation of unstable lakes, prone to hazardous outburst floods. Today’s study provides a vital missing piece of evidence for a ground-breaking lawsuit seeking compensation from an energy company, RWE, for climate change impacts.
This new research establishes a ‘full set’ of links from human-made greenhouse-gas emissions to the substantial risk of a dangerous outburst flood from Lake Palcacocha, high in the Peruvian Andes. This flood threatens to inundate the city of Huaraz.
Rupert Stuart-Smith, lead author of the study says, ‘We found that human influence on climate – through greenhouse gas emissions – is responsible for virtually all of the warming that has been observed in the region.
‘The study shows that warming has caused the retreat of the Palcaraju glacier which, in turn, has increased the flood risk. Crucially, this establishes a direct link between emissions and the need to implement protective measures now, as well as any damages caused by flooding in future.’
According to the study, ‘The magnitude of human-induced warming equals between 85 and 105%...of the observed 1°C warming since 1880 in this region. We conclude that it is virtually certain (>99% probability) that the retreat of Palcaraju glacier to the present day cannot be explained by natural variability alone...
‘The worldwide retreat of mountain glaciers is one of the most prominent impacts of climate change in public discourse and an established consequence of anthropogenic climate change, with Andean glaciers among the fastest retreating.’
Professor Gerard Roe, study author and researcher at the University of Washington says, ‘The scientific challenge was to provide the clearest and cleanest assessment of the physical linkages between climate change and the changing flood hazard.’
‘Around the world, the retreat of mountain glaciers is one of the clearest indicators of climate change,’ according to Professor Roe. ‘Outburst floods threaten communities in many mountainous regions, but this risk is particularly severe in Huaraz, as well as elsewhere in the Andes and in countries such as Nepal and Bhutan, where vulnerable populations live in the path of the potential floodwaters.’
The study provides key new evidence for Lliuya v. RWE, a lawsuit in the German courts. Saúl Luciano Lliuya, a farmer from Huaraz, is suing RWE, Germany’s largest electricity producer, for the costs of preventing harms which would result from an outburst flood from Lake Palcacocha. The study’s establishment of a clear, linear causal chain between greenhouse gas emissions and severe outburst flood risk could help resolve critical outstanding questions in the case.
Professor Thom Wetzer, Founding Director of the Oxford Sustainable Law Programme, says, ‘A number of new lawsuits are attempting to hold high-emission companies responsible for the costs of climate change.
‘Such claims require rigorous scientific evidence quantifying the links between emissions and impacts – as has been provided in this study. It is now up to litigators to translate the science into high-impact legal arguments. Whether or not this particular case proceeds, it shows there is huge potential to leverage the power of the law to hold private companies liable for climate-change related impacts.’
In technical terms, the study took a three-step approach to evaluate the link between greenhouse gas emissions and the flood hazard:
- It used standard Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) methods to evaluate the role of human emissions on observed temperature increases in the region;
- It used a glacier model to assess the relationship between this warming and the retreat of Palcaraju glacier and;
- It used two methods of outburst flood hazard assessment to investigate the effect of the resultant growth of Lake Palcacocha on the flood risk faced by Huaraz.
Dr Friederike Otto, Associate Director of Oxford’s Environmental Change Institute, says, ‘We know that global warming is a real game changer for certain extreme weather events such as heatwaves, making them more likely and severe.
‘The next challenge is to translate this scientific understanding of cause and effect into evidence that holds up in courts. As human influence and our ability to quantify it differs strongly from place to place and across different types of events, this is far from straightforward. But as these events threaten communities around the world, and loss and damage from climate change are far from being top priority for policy makers, this kind of research is needed more than ever before.’
Notes for Editors
This is not the first time Huaraz has been threatened by climate change. In 1941, an outburst flood from Lake Palcacocha killed at least 1800 people. The study also found this flood to be influenced by human-induced climate change – making it one of the earliest fatal impacts of climate change to have been identified globally.
Since the 1970s, engineering works have sought to keep up with the growing flood risk and make the lake safe.
The Environmental Change Institute was established in 1991. Its aim is to organise and promote interdisciplinary research on the nature, causes and impact of environmental change and to contribute to the development of management strategies for coping with future environmental change.
The University of Oxford
The university has been placed number one in the Times Higher Education World University Rankings for the fifth year running, and at the heart of this success is our ground-breaking research and innovation. Oxford is world-famous for research excellence and home to some of the most talented people from across the globe. Our work helps the lives of millions, solving real-world problems through a huge network of partnerships and collaborations. The breadth and interdisciplinary nature of our research sparks imaginative and inventive insights and solutions.