Oxford Vice-Chancellor calls for ‘evidence-based’ immigration debate

7 October 2014

Plea to end to student migrant targets as part of wide-ranging defence of Higher Education’s benefit  

Political parties must respect research-based evidence in forming their election policies, particularly in the heated area of immigration, Oxford University’s Vice-Chancellor declared today.

In his annual Oration to the University, Professor Andrew Hamilton made the case for increased public investment in universities by outlining the many benefits that world-class higher education brings to the UK. These include providing information and expertise that can improve the quality of political debate and decision-making.

Professor Hamilton gave as an example the issue of student visas, where he believes current policy is directly harming UK interests. He told Oxford University’s Congregation: “Wherever I travel in the world, particularly in China and India, one question persists. Why has the UK adopted a visa system so hostile to student entry? I do my best to answer but, frankly, the question baffles me as well. For the first time in decades, the number of international students at our universities has dropped, most markedly from India. Why are we doing this to them – and to ourselves?”

Research by Oxford’s own Migration Observatory, Professor Hamilton argued, had shown that the public do not link overseas student numbers with immigration issues. He said: “Study is the least frequent answer given when the public are asked what they consider the motives for migration to be. Student migration simply isn’t an issue for them and there are few votes in restricting overseas student numbers. There are signs that this reality is beginning to dawn across the political spectrum; something to be welcomed and encouraged ahead of the election.”

Professor Hamilton said the example of immigration gave “some sense of what universities like Oxford can bring to complex political and policy challenges; ones that defy the temptation to reach for simple or simplistic answers. In essence, we can provide the data, the understanding and the analysis to underpin arguments and the possible solutions for the problems we all face.”

In a wide-ranging survey of higher education’s public benefit, Professor Hamilton also addressed Oxford’s regional and international impact.

The Vice-Chancellor described the University as crucial to the region’s economic ambitions. Oxford had been instrumental in shaping two of this year’s major funding announcements – the City Deal and the Oxfordshire Growth Deal – around knowledge based growth. Over time, these will unleash investment of more than £1.3bn in local infrastructure and innovation. The University will be at the heart of both deals, driving new initiatives in high-tech spin-outs, life science enterprises and the region’s world-leading cluster of superconductor businesses.

Professor Hamilton added: “Our economic involvement does not end with these ambitious deals. We understand the problems our region faces, great and small. Wherever there is an issue to be tackled, you are likely to find an Oxford researcher working on the solution.”

Turning to the University’s international contribution, Professor Hamilton paid tribute to the 1500 staff of the Oxford Tropical Medicine Laboratories, working around the world in the fight against malaria, HIV-AIDS, tuberculosis and many others. Following the devastating outbreak of Ebola in West Africa, Oxford has been called in to spearhead two global alliances to tackle the growing tragedy. Trials of potential new treatments are being fast-tracked in West Africa, led by Dr Peter Horby of the Centre for Tropical Medicine and Global Health and ISARIC, the International Severe Acute Respiratory and Emerging Infection Consortium. Meanwhile the Jenner Institute, under the directorship of Professor Adrian Hill, is leading the effort to find a safe and reliable vaccine to guard against the disease.

Professor Hamilton was clear that universities should be free to follow their own research agendas, rather than have them dictated by economic and political interests. He argued that often, research’s greatest impact came from unforeseen consequences. For example, doctoral student Torsten Reil’s zoological research led to the creation of Oxford-based digital animation company NaturalMotion, valued at more $500m in an international deal earlier this year.

However, Professor Hamilton argued that the undisputed benefit of Oxford and other UK universities was not matched by the level of public investment in the sector. Recent figures showed that UK public investment higher education, at 0.9 per cent of GDP, was one of the lowest in Europe and below the OECD average. He also pointed to “dismaying” government figures showing that research and development investment fell to 1.72 per cent of investment in 2012, at a time when most international competitors were increasing spending.

Professor Hamilton concluded his address: “...It is still all too rare to hear higher education described, accurately, as just about the most important investment a nation can make on behalf of its citizens, especially when those citizens are living in a knowledge-based global economy. That’s why I have somewhat  limited expectation, come the general election, that properly developed policies on higher education (as opposed to vain-glorious point-scoring on past crimes and misdemeanours) will take up much of the politicians’ time or attention. That’s sad -- because it is exactly the sort of issue on which a real effort to find a new, meaningful consensus between the parties would be of immense benefit — benefit, of course, to the students and to the universities of the future, but also, as I  hope to have demonstrated this morning, hugely beneficial to the public good.”

The Oration took place at 12 noon in Convocation House at the University of Oxford. For more information, or for the full text of the Oration, contact the Oxford University press office on 01865 280528 or [email protected]

About the Migration Observatory

Based at the ESRC Centre on Migration, Policy and Society (COMPAS) at the University of Oxford, the Migration Observatory provides independent, authoritative, evidence-based analysis of data on migration and migrants in the UK, to inform media, public and policy debates, and to generate high quality research on international migration and public policy issues. The Observatory’s analysis involves experts from a wide range of disciplines and departments at the University of Oxford.  The Migration Observatory is core funded by: Unbound Philanthropy; the Esmée Fairbairn Foundation, the Paul Hamlyn Foundation and the Barrow Cadbury Trust.   The Centre on Migration, Policy and Society (COMPAS) at the University of Oxford conducts high quality research in order to develop theory and knowledge, inform policy-making and public debate, and engage users of research within the field of migration. For further details see the COMPAS website: www.compas.ox.ac.uk/.  COMPAS was established in 2003 with a five-year grant from the Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) www.esrc.ac.uk/. A second ESRC grant was provided in 2008, which supported the centre until 2014. COMPAS funding continues tocomefrom a variety of charities, philanthropic organisations and research councils see http://www.compas.ox.ac.uk/about/funders/ for details.