23 December 2015
What binds military fighters or terrorists together so tightly that they are willing to sacrifice their own lives for their causes? Previous research has shown that such extreme behaviour can be driven by ‘identity fusion’, a strong sense of ‘oneness’ with their group. Oxford University researchers have now shed new light on the role that shared emotional experiences plays in this fusion between people’s personal and group identities. In their paper, published in the journal PLOS ONE, they describe three studies. The first two, based on online questionnaires with people living in Northern Ireland and Boston, USA, reveal that people who share extremely bad experiences together fuse more with their respective groups and a reflective process appears to link the shared traumatic events with the group’s identity. An experiment also shows how just thinking about a collectively traumatic event increases a sense of oneness with the group.
In the first study, 200 people of Irish and British descent in Northern Ireland who had lived during ‘The Troubles’ were asked about their negative experiences as a Unionist or Republican; how frequently they had suffered for being a Republican or Unionist; and how they rated their suffering. They then answered questions about how often they reflected on these shared negative experiences and, finally, how fused they felt with Republicanism or Unionism. The findings suggest that the level of an individual’s suffering as a member of their group can be linked with their level of identity fusion, and this connection forms because of a period of reflection on their shared experiences.
The paper also reports two other studies with residents of Boston. They were asked about how they were directly or indirectly affected by the 2013 Boston Marathon Bombing, a terrorist attack that killed three people and injured more than 260. Unlike participants from Northern Ireland, Boston residents had not experienced a long conflict, but a sudden, one-off, seemingly random attack. Again researchers found that those most affected by the event thought more about their experiences. This, in turn, predicted how strongly their personal identity fused with the City of Boston.
Researchers lastly carried out an experiment to see the effects of reviving memories of the Boston Bombing. Half of a sample of almost 100 people was randomly put into the ‘Boston Bombing group’, in which participants had to vividly recall their memories of that incident and write them down, and think specifically about how they and others they knew had been affected by the event. The other half, meanwhile, was given a different task of remembering more mundane things they had done recently in Boston, such as running errands or shopping. Afterwards, researchers assessed the overlap between their personal and group identities. Using standard psychological measures, they found that those who had been primed about the Boston Bombing had a heightened sense of oneness with the city.
Lead author Dr Jonathan Jong, from the School of Anthropology at the University of Oxford, said: ‘Previous research has shown that people with high levels of fusion are more likely to back extreme action taken for the sake of the group, particularly when they feel their group is threatened. We find that memories of shared bad experiences at the hands of hostile outsiders can lead to fusion. It is important to increase our understanding of the psychological causes behind intense social bonding and extremism if we are to develop effective interventions to stem the tide of conflicts we are experiencing in the world today. One possibility might be to try to disrupt the process of reflection that seems so important in connecting shared trauma with social bonding.’
The research was done as part of the Ritual Project, funded by the UK Economic Social Research Council. Project leader and co-author of the research paper, Professor Harvey Whitehouse, also from the University of Oxford, said: ‘This research into the role of shared suffering in identity fusion supports earlier project findings, including our studies of militias in Libya during and after the revolution in 2011. There we found that fighters who had faced the most traumatic ordeals of frontline combat were more fused with friends in their battalions than with their families, whereas those who had faced less extreme experiences in the conflict were significantly more fused with family than with fellow fighters. Fusion is key to explaining the willingness of armed combatants to fight and die for one another. Understanding the mechanisms involved may help us to de-fuse combatants or harness their fusion in the service of peaceful outcomes.’
For more information, contact the University of Oxford News office on +44 (0)1865 280534 or firstname.lastname@example.org
Notes for Editors:
- The paper, ‘Shared negative experiences lead to identity fusion via personal reflection’, is due to be published in PLOS ONE.
- Once live, it will be available at http://dx.plos.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0145611
- The paper’s authors are Jonathan Jong, Harvey Whitehouse, Christopher Kavanagh and Justin Lane, who are all from the University of Oxford. The researchers are part of an international research team engaged in The Ritual Project funded by the UK Economic Social Research Council.
- More about the project
- The Ritual Project is an inter-disciplinary, multi-centre effort to discover the origins and functions of ritualistic acts in human cognition and culture, in the formation of co-operative communities, the transmission of ideas and behaviours, and the eruption of inter-group conflict. Through cautious ethnography, quantitative archaeology and historiography, large-scale surveys, and laboratory- and field-based experiments, the researchers aim to understand where rituals come from, and how they have affected and still affect the way we learn and live and love and fight and die. It involves researchers from all around the world, including the University of Oxford; Royal Holloway University of London; Queen’s University Belfast; University of Texas in Austin; SUNY Binghamton; UNED Spain; National University of Singapore; University of New South Wales; University of Otago; Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Norte; University College London; University of Bath; Hokkaido University; University of Auckland; Stanford University; University of Hertfordshire; Coventry University; University of Exeter; University of Michigan; Harvard University; University of Connecticut; Trinity College Dublin; Université Montpellier 2; Western Sydney University and Macquarie University.